From NAFTA to USMCA: Two’s Company, Three’s a Crowd
Abstract
The renegotiation of NAFTA was surrounded by a dramatic atmosphere, just as Canadian Minister of Foreign Affairs Chrystia Freeland predicted. The negotiations took place against a backdrop of unilateral trade measures, President Trump’s mercantilist approach to trade policy, and the United States’ specified preference for bilateral trade deals. This article argues that, for the most part, economic, political and cultural relations in the NAFTA countries are bilateral in nature, but with important trilateral production chains in specific sectors, most notably in the automotive sector. Beyond these trilateral sectors, the relationship between Canada and Mexico plays a relatively minor role. However, replacing NAFTA with bilateral agreements would have placed Canada and Mexico at a disadvantage, relative to the United States, in terms of attracting foreign direct investment. Nevertheless, Canadian and Mexican interests do not always coincide, nor do their negotiating positions. For example, Mexico was willing to give up Chapter 19 dispute settlement for trade remedies, whereas Canada insisted on keeping it in place. In end, USMCA Chapter 10 preserves this dispute settlement mechanism for all three parties. Canada was willing to give up NAFTA Chapter 11 on foreign investment disputes, whereas Mexico accepted a modified version. The result is a trilateral agreement with significant bilateral elements, as well as global elements that will serve as a possible model in future megaregional and multilateral negotiations.Keywords:
USMCA, NAFTA, negotiations, United States, Mexico, Canada, renegotiationsReferences
Canis, B., Villarreal, A., & Jones, V. C. (2017). NAFTA and Motor Vehicle Trade (pp. 25): Congressional Research Service.
CIA Factbook. (2017a). Percentage of trade with NAFTA partners Retrieved 14-08-2018, from CIA FACTBOOK
CIA Factbook. (2017b). Trade and GDP of NAFTA Countries 2017 CIA Factbook Retrieved 14-08-2018, from CIA The World Factbook
Condon, B. J. (2018). Captain America and the Tarnishing of the Crown: The Feud between the WTO Appellate Body and the USA. Journal of World Trade, 52(4), 535-556.
Condon, B. J., & Sinha, T. (2003). Drawing lines in sand and snow : border security and North American economic integration. London, N.Y.: M.E. Sharpe.
Dade, C., Ciuriak, D., Dadkhah, A., & Xiao, J. (2017). The Art of the Trade Deal: Quantifying the benefits of a TPP without the United States, Canada West Foundation (pp. 40).
Dattu, R., Sathananthan, G., & Schappert, T. (2017). The Trump administration takes aim at Chapter 19 of NAFTA. Retrieved Dec. 1, 2017, from https://www.osler.com/en/resources/cross-border/2017/international-trade-brief-trump-administration-ta
Doern, G. B., & Tomlin, B. W. (1991). Faith and Fear: The Free Trade Story. Toronto: Stoddart Publishing Co.
González-Barrera, A. (2015). More Mexicans Leaving Than Coming to the U.S. Retrieved Nov. 6th, 2018, from http://www.pewhispanic.org/2015/11/19/more-mexicans-leaving-than-coming-to-the-u-s/
Government of Canada. (2017). Factsheet: Mexico. from http://www.canadainternational.gc.ca/mexico-mexique/fs_mexico-fd_mexique.aspx?lang=eng
Hudec, R. E. (1990). The GATT legal system and world trade diplomacy: Butterworth Legal Publishers.
Lester, S. (2017). USTR’s NAFTA Chapter 20 Proposals. Retrieved from https://worldtradelaw.typepad.com/ielpblog/2017/09/nafta-chapter-20-proposals.html
Lighthizer, R. (2017). Trade Policy Priorities: Robert Lighthizer, Unites States Trade Representative [Retrieved from https://www.csis.org/analysis/us-trade-policy-priorities-robert-lighthizer-united-states-trade-representative
Lipsey, R. G. (1994). The NAFTA : what's in, what's out, what's next / Richard G. Lipsey, Daniel Schwanen, Ronald J. Wonnacott. Toronto: C.D. Howe Institute.
López, L. A. (2012). La necesidad de crear un Órgano de Apelación para arbitrajes Inversionista-Estado en CIADI. Revista de Derecho Económico Internacional, 3(1), 20.
Macrory, P. (2002). NAFTA Chapter 19: A Successful Experiment in International Trade Dispute Resolution. The Border Papers, C.D. Howe Institute, 168, 27.
Maurer, N. (2006). Was NAFTA Necessary? Trade Policy and Relative Economic Failure since 1982 HBS Working Paper, 43(06), 36.
Mavroidis, P. (2018). From Roosevelt to Reagan to Trump: the Decay of US Internationalism. Retrieved from https://worldtradelaw.typepad.com/ielpblog/2018/09/guest-post-from-roosevelt-to-reagan-to-trump-the-decay-of-us-internationalism.html
Miranda, J. (2018). Whither NAFTA? (Part VII: Why Chapter Nineteen is not Worth the Three Amigos Becoming the Two Amigos). 2018, from http://regulatingforglobalization.com/2018/09/13/whither-nafta-part-vii-chapter-nineteen-not-worth-three-amigos-becoming-two-amigos/
OECD. Multilateral Agreement on Investment. Retrieved Nov. 6, 2018, from http://www.oecd.org/investment/internationalinvestmentagreements/multilateralagreementoninvestment.htm
Office of the Chief Economist. (2016). Economic Impact of Canada’s Potential Participation in the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement. 2018, from http://international.gc.ca/economist-economiste/analysis-analyse/tpp_ei-re_ptp.aspx?lang=eng
Pauwelyn, J. (2006). Adding Sweeteners to Softwood Lumber: The WTO-NAFTA “Spaghetti Bowl” Is Cooking. Journal of International Economic Law, 9(1), 197-206.
Ramírez, E. (2006). Political & Quasi-Adjudicative Dispute Settlement Models in European Union Free Trade Agreements: Is the quasi-adjudicative model a trend or is it just another model? WTO Economic Research and Statistics Division, ERSD 2006-09, 45.
Riggs, A. R., & Velk, T. (1993). Beyond NAFTA: An Economic, Political and Sociological Perspective: The Fraser Institute.
Secretaría de Economía. (2017). Estadísticas de Comercio Exterior de México. Retrieved 14-08-2018, from Secretaría de Economía
Statistics Canada. (2017). Canadian international merchandise trade: Annual review. Canada: Statistics Canada.
Stokes, B. (2017). Views of NAFTA less positive – and more partisan – in U.S. than in Canada and Mexico. Retrieved Nov. 6, 2018, from http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/05/09/views-of-nafta-less-positive-and-more-partisan-in-u-s-than-in-canada-and-mexico/
U.S. Census Bureau. (1995-2018). Foreign Trade Division. from https://www.census.gov/foreign-trade/index.html
U.S. Energy Information Administration. (2017). Canada is the United States’ largest partner for energy trade. Retrieved Nov. 6, 2018, from https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=34332
U.S. Energy Information Administration. (2018). The value of U.S. energy exports to Mexico exceeded import value for third year in a row. Retrieved Nov. 6, 2018, from https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=35332
United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement Text (2018).
USTR. (2017). Summary of Objectives for the NAFTA Renegotiation (pp. 18): Office of the United States Trade Representative, Executive Office of the President.
Vice, M., & Chwe, H. (2017). Mexican Views of the U.S. Turn Sharply Negative. Retrieved Nov. 6, 2018, from http://www.pewglobal.org/2017/09/14/mexican-views-of-the-u-s-turn-sharply-negative/
Welch, D., & Merril, D. (2017). Why Trump Tariffs on Mexican Cars Probably Won’t Stop Job Flight. Retrieved Nov. 6, 2018, from https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2017-trump-mexico-auto-jobs/
CIA Factbook. (2017a). Percentage of trade with NAFTA partners Retrieved 14-08-2018, from CIA FACTBOOK
CIA Factbook. (2017b). Trade and GDP of NAFTA Countries 2017 CIA Factbook Retrieved 14-08-2018, from CIA The World Factbook
Condon, B. J. (2018). Captain America and the Tarnishing of the Crown: The Feud between the WTO Appellate Body and the USA. Journal of World Trade, 52(4), 535-556.
Condon, B. J., & Sinha, T. (2003). Drawing lines in sand and snow : border security and North American economic integration. London, N.Y.: M.E. Sharpe.
Dade, C., Ciuriak, D., Dadkhah, A., & Xiao, J. (2017). The Art of the Trade Deal: Quantifying the benefits of a TPP without the United States, Canada West Foundation (pp. 40).
Dattu, R., Sathananthan, G., & Schappert, T. (2017). The Trump administration takes aim at Chapter 19 of NAFTA. Retrieved Dec. 1, 2017, from https://www.osler.com/en/resources/cross-border/2017/international-trade-brief-trump-administration-ta
Doern, G. B., & Tomlin, B. W. (1991). Faith and Fear: The Free Trade Story. Toronto: Stoddart Publishing Co.
González-Barrera, A. (2015). More Mexicans Leaving Than Coming to the U.S. Retrieved Nov. 6th, 2018, from http://www.pewhispanic.org/2015/11/19/more-mexicans-leaving-than-coming-to-the-u-s/
Government of Canada. (2017). Factsheet: Mexico. from http://www.canadainternational.gc.ca/mexico-mexique/fs_mexico-fd_mexique.aspx?lang=eng
Hudec, R. E. (1990). The GATT legal system and world trade diplomacy: Butterworth Legal Publishers.
Lester, S. (2017). USTR’s NAFTA Chapter 20 Proposals. Retrieved from https://worldtradelaw.typepad.com/ielpblog/2017/09/nafta-chapter-20-proposals.html
Lighthizer, R. (2017). Trade Policy Priorities: Robert Lighthizer, Unites States Trade Representative [Retrieved from https://www.csis.org/analysis/us-trade-policy-priorities-robert-lighthizer-united-states-trade-representative
Lipsey, R. G. (1994). The NAFTA : what's in, what's out, what's next / Richard G. Lipsey, Daniel Schwanen, Ronald J. Wonnacott. Toronto: C.D. Howe Institute.
López, L. A. (2012). La necesidad de crear un Órgano de Apelación para arbitrajes Inversionista-Estado en CIADI. Revista de Derecho Económico Internacional, 3(1), 20.
Macrory, P. (2002). NAFTA Chapter 19: A Successful Experiment in International Trade Dispute Resolution. The Border Papers, C.D. Howe Institute, 168, 27.
Maurer, N. (2006). Was NAFTA Necessary? Trade Policy and Relative Economic Failure since 1982 HBS Working Paper, 43(06), 36.
Mavroidis, P. (2018). From Roosevelt to Reagan to Trump: the Decay of US Internationalism. Retrieved from https://worldtradelaw.typepad.com/ielpblog/2018/09/guest-post-from-roosevelt-to-reagan-to-trump-the-decay-of-us-internationalism.html
Miranda, J. (2018). Whither NAFTA? (Part VII: Why Chapter Nineteen is not Worth the Three Amigos Becoming the Two Amigos). 2018, from http://regulatingforglobalization.com/2018/09/13/whither-nafta-part-vii-chapter-nineteen-not-worth-three-amigos-becoming-two-amigos/
OECD. Multilateral Agreement on Investment. Retrieved Nov. 6, 2018, from http://www.oecd.org/investment/internationalinvestmentagreements/multilateralagreementoninvestment.htm
Office of the Chief Economist. (2016). Economic Impact of Canada’s Potential Participation in the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement. 2018, from http://international.gc.ca/economist-economiste/analysis-analyse/tpp_ei-re_ptp.aspx?lang=eng
Pauwelyn, J. (2006). Adding Sweeteners to Softwood Lumber: The WTO-NAFTA “Spaghetti Bowl” Is Cooking. Journal of International Economic Law, 9(1), 197-206.
Ramírez, E. (2006). Political & Quasi-Adjudicative Dispute Settlement Models in European Union Free Trade Agreements: Is the quasi-adjudicative model a trend or is it just another model? WTO Economic Research and Statistics Division, ERSD 2006-09, 45.
Riggs, A. R., & Velk, T. (1993). Beyond NAFTA: An Economic, Political and Sociological Perspective: The Fraser Institute.
Secretaría de Economía. (2017). Estadísticas de Comercio Exterior de México. Retrieved 14-08-2018, from Secretaría de Economía
Statistics Canada. (2017). Canadian international merchandise trade: Annual review. Canada: Statistics Canada.
Stokes, B. (2017). Views of NAFTA less positive – and more partisan – in U.S. than in Canada and Mexico. Retrieved Nov. 6, 2018, from http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/05/09/views-of-nafta-less-positive-and-more-partisan-in-u-s-than-in-canada-and-mexico/
U.S. Census Bureau. (1995-2018). Foreign Trade Division. from https://www.census.gov/foreign-trade/index.html
U.S. Energy Information Administration. (2017). Canada is the United States’ largest partner for energy trade. Retrieved Nov. 6, 2018, from https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=34332
U.S. Energy Information Administration. (2018). The value of U.S. energy exports to Mexico exceeded import value for third year in a row. Retrieved Nov. 6, 2018, from https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=35332
United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement Text (2018).
USTR. (2017). Summary of Objectives for the NAFTA Renegotiation (pp. 18): Office of the United States Trade Representative, Executive Office of the President.
Vice, M., & Chwe, H. (2017). Mexican Views of the U.S. Turn Sharply Negative. Retrieved Nov. 6, 2018, from http://www.pewglobal.org/2017/09/14/mexican-views-of-the-u-s-turn-sharply-negative/
Welch, D., & Merril, D. (2017). Why Trump Tariffs on Mexican Cars Probably Won’t Stop Job Flight. Retrieved Nov. 6, 2018, from https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2017-trump-mexico-auto-jobs/
